How to find the perfect Scotch Whisky in South Africa

Whisky store with header How to find the perfect Scotch Whisky in South Africa

Scotland might be a small country but they are one of the largest whisky producers in the world. They are at the top of the list when it comes to popularity around the globe. Unless you’re in another major whisky-producing country like America, the Scotch whisky selection is often the largest in the store; the same goes for their online shops. It can become very intimidating, and you might not find what you’re looking for or walk out without buying anything.

Understanding how different countries and stores categorize their whisky will help you narrow your options down to specific barrel finishes and flavours. Scotland would probably start with their regions or types, while American whiskey is often categorized first by type of whisky. Here’s how you can start finding the Scotch you’ve been looking for, especially in South Africa where options are varied and limited.

Region

Scotland has 6 major regions of whisky-making and is often the first choice when narrowing down what you’re looking for. These regions might be in a relatively small area but they often have vast differences in climate and other important environmental conditions known as terroir which can influence even the smallest details of the spirit. Even though the local laws don’t recognize them all individually, here are the six relatively distinct Scotch whisky regions.

Highland

This is Scotland’s largest scotch region, spanning from the northwest of Glasgow to the Northern islands. Whisky varies quite a bit across this region due to the area it spans.  

The Northern regions are often categorized by richer, sweeter, and more full-bodied whiskies. The southern regions are known for their slightly drier, lighter, and fruitier expressions, similar to the Lowlands. The Western region, being closer to Islay might have more full-bodied and peated whiskies similar to the iconic island region.

Some popular Highland whiskies include:

Ardmore, Ben Nevis, Blair Athol, Dalmore, Dalwhinnie, Deanston, Glendronach, Glengoyne, The Glenmorangie, Glenugie, Invergordon, Loch Lomond, Old Pulteney, Teaninich, Tomatin and Wolfburn

Speyside

Speyside is often seen as a subregion of the Highlands but it has its special characteristics. It’s not only a small region but is one of the most densely-populated whisky regions in the world. It also gets its name from the River Spey. The region can thank its abundance of quality water from the river, which many distillers use in their malts.

You can often categorize the flavor profile with winter holiday flavours, like honeyed pears and apples along with other stone fruit. They are often known for their spice notes and of course sherry, due to the popular use of ex-sherry casks.

Some popular Highland whiskies include:

Aberlour, Aultmore, The Balvenie, Benromach, Cardhu, Dalwhinnie, Dufftown, Glen Grant, Glen Moray, Glenfarclas, Glenfiddich, Glenlivet, Linkwood, Longmorn, The Macallan, Speyburn, Speyside, Tamdhu, Tamnavulin, Tormintoul and Tormore.

Islay

If you’re looking for something smoky, this is probably where you want to be. Islay is an island off the coast of Scotland that’s known for its peated whiskies. Peat is made from plant material that’s compressed and decayed over thousands of years. It’s great for fuel and so, was the perfect substance to use in the malting process, giving whiskies their smoky flavour.

Islay whisky is known for being heavily peated, although Bunnahabhain and Bruichladdach also make unpeated malts.

Islay distilleries include Ardbeg, Ardnahoe, Bowmore, Bruichladdich, Bunnahabhain, Caol Ila, Kilchoman, Lagavulin, and Laphroaig.

Lowland

If you’re looking for something lighter and smoother, you might lean towards the Lowland expressions. Like many Irish whiskeys, many lowland malts and blends are triple distilled, giving it a “smoother” experience. Rarely peated, lowland whiskies are often used in blends due to their gentler flavours.

Lowland whiskies are known for being light, sweet, floral, and gentle. They’re often experienced as creamy and “like dessert”.

Some popular Lowland whisky distilleries include:

Aerstone, Auchentoshen, Bladnoch, Bonnington, Borders, Daftmill, Eden Mill, The Glasgow Distillery, Glenkinchie, Holyrood and Kingsbarns.

Campbeltown

The smallest whisky region is also often known as the home of whisky. The region doesn’t form part of Islay but the distilleries here are potentially what inspired the region. These whiskies are briny, smoky, oily, and very hearty. You might find toffee, vanilla, and baking spice notes here too.

Distilleries include Glen Scotia, Glengyle, and Springbank.

The Islands

Scotland has many islands surrounding it, forming part of this great whisky nation. The peat found here tends to add more aromatic notes to their whiskies than in the Islay region. This region is also becoming more popular, providing the perfect start for younger distilleries.

Distilleries include Abhainn Dearg, Arran, Highland Park, Isle of Raasay, Jura, Scapa, Talisker, Tobermory, and Torabhaig.

Scotch whisky type

There are many types of Scotch whisky being made but single malt is often seen as the pinnacle with single grain and blends lower on the list. However, as whisky becomes more specialized, blending houses are becoming very popular.

Single Malt

Single malt whisky often confuses with how it’s categorized, but here’s the deal. Single malt whisky needs only three ingredients, malted barley, water, and yeast. It’s also only allowed to be made and bottled at a single distillery.A single malt whisky can include whisky from various barrels and maturation ages, as long as it adheres to the above rules.

This style of whisky often presents more woody and oaky, and full-bodied, with a more “smooth” mouthfeel. Single malt isn’t usually smoky but some might experience more wood char in its place.

Single Grain

Single-grain whisky contains barley and one or more other cereal grains, usually wheat or corn. Single grain is, like single malt, still made at a single distillery for your enjoyment.

This style of whisky is often sweeter and has a lighter body to it.

Blended Scotch

As whisky becomes more popular, whisky-makers are getting more adventurous and experimental with what they can accomplish. Even though blended whisky is often turned away, you should give it another chance.

There are specialized blending houses like Johnnie Walker and Compass Box that put in many hours with years of experience, and tasting thousands of whiskies from various barrels to create special expressions and releases.

You can also read my article about these differences in more detail, HERE.

The age of whisky

Especially when buying gifts, you’ll see a label with the age expression on the bottle. This number represents the youngest whisky in the bottle. The maturation age confirms the length of time that whisky was kept.

Aging whisky was done completely by accident. After the spirit was made, it needed to be transported, so barrels were used. Some of these even contained fish at some point. Depending on the amount, they were stored and often forgotten about before somebody opened it up and realized the flavour had changed.

You might think that the bigger the number, the better the whisky, but this isn’t necessarily true. Sometimes, the whisky just didn’t have the characteristics they were looking for until a certain age or they eventually just used the older whisky to blend to add something different to another expression.

Don’t let the number on the bottle fool you too much but we can’t deny that seeing a more matured whisky looks great on the shelf.

If you’re in South Africa, you’ll find hundreds of different bottles of Scotch on the shelves or online, even with a limited range compared to where it’s made in Scotland.

Finding your favourite whisky is a journey, so starting to filter them out can be daunting. Together with regions, distilleries, and even specific expressions, you can start the search more easily.

Why do South Africans need to drink more peated whisky?

Glass of smoky whisky with a fire background

If there’s one thing everybody in South Africa knows about, it’s that one of our favourite pastimes is having a braai. Whether we’re camping or having friends and family over for the weekend, we love lighting a fire with charcoal and wood before cooking a variety of meat over the flames. At the same time, we’re often having some drinks with whisky, be it neat or mixed, as one of the popular options. However, you don’t see a lot of peated Scotch whisky on drinks tables or bars.

Peated whisky, especially Scotch is known for its hefty smoky smell and flavour that can either caress your senses or overpower your palate. But for a country that loves a braai day filled with fantastic smoky smells and flavours, peated whisky is not always accessible.  

What is peat and how does it impact whisky?

Peat is a spongy material formed by the partial decomposition of organic matter, primarily plant material, in wetlands such as swamps, muskegs, bogs, fens, and moors. It’s formed over thousands of years and compressed. Beyond its considerable ecological importance, peat is economically important as a carbon sink, as a source of fuel, and as a raw material in horticulture and other industries. Like the whisky industry in Scotland and Ireland.

Peat is often used for fuel and fireplaces but when whisky makers wanted to dry out their barley before making their single malts, they used something widely available and known for burning well. They discovered the very different and much-loved flavours the peat smoke added to the spirit, and a whole new style was created. The more time the barley is exposed to the peat smoke, the more intense the flavour.

Light and dark Malted barley
Malted barley is the main ingredient in peated single malt whisky.

Peat on its own doesn’t taste of anything due to having a neutral PH, but when it’s burned and used in whisky-making, provides subtle smells and often dominant flavours. On the nose, you’ll often smell burning wood and meat but you might also find fresh damp earth. When tasting, the smoky flavour can be overpowering, but you might find a meaty or protein flavour and mouth feel. Some malts may be light and oily, others rich and heavy, some fruity and spicy, others nutty or sweet. Everything individual distilleries use and the amount they use will change what you smell and taste, and you never need to worry about “being wrong” because everybody tastes and smells differently.

How do South Africans experience smoky whisky?

As mentioned before, South Africans often prefer drinking blended whisky instead of single malt, often due to price or what we add to the glass. That doesn’t mean that we don’t experience smoke in our drinks, but it’s often part of a blend, meaning it’s not going to overwhelm our taste buds. Some of our favourite “smoky” whiskies are expressions like Johnnie Walker Black, Green, and Blue Labels. These expressions often get their peated spirits from the Islay region but the underrated Cardhu (a key component of Johnnie Walker) also provides some smoke to some bottles.

Johnnie Walker bottle with a glass full of whisky
One of South Africa’s favourite Scotch whiskies with a bit of smoke, is Johnnie Walker. Photo via Unsplash

In terms of popular smoky single malt, Lagavulin 16 year is high on the list thanks to celebrities like Nick Offerman with Highland Park 12, and their interesting bottle, on our shelves. But do they provide the flavours that pair well with a braai?

How can South Africans enjoy more smoke?

South Africans are a hearty bunch. So, when we celebrate, we often have a braai full of steaks, chops and boerewors. We can smell our neighbours doing the same thing, and that’s when we realise that we’re having a truly South African experience with friends and family. So, are there any whiskies we could add to our overall experience as we enjoy the conversation and the smells of wood fires with a range of meat on the braai?

Even though single malt can get quite pricey, many of the popular distilleries that specialise in peat have added more accessible bottles to their core range. A fan favourite, Ardbeg Wee Beastie, is a 5-year aged single malt that has a reputation for tasting like bacon being cooked directly on hot ash. If you’re in the mood for something similar but more complex and refined, Ardbeg Uigeadial, Bowmore, Talisker, or Caol Ila might be more up your street.

Ardbeg is popular for being one of the smokiest whiskies on the market.

But Islay isn’t the only popular smoky Scotch-makers. As Islay tends to specialise in the smoke, the Highland and Speyside regions often provide mostly non-peated Scotch with some peaty expressions to round out their ranges. Benriach Smoke Season has become more accessible locally with Oban and anCnoc from the Highlands providing something completely different.

If you’re a fan of smooth Irish Whiskey, you’ll be happy to know that they also provide some smoke to their single malts. A fan favourite, Connemara Peated provides your palate with wafts of smoke and some honey sweetness that would provide a great gateway to those unfamiliar with smoke. If you want to take it down another notch, try an Irish whiskey that only uses a small percentage of whiskey aged in a barrel that used to have peated Scotch, like Dunville’s 1808 which provides the idea of smoke without overpowering your taste buds.

Should South Africans enjoy more peat?

Even though my journey with whisky has barely left the station, as a South African who loves a braai with my favourite people, I think the answer is always “YES”.

We already have the foundation of enjoying the smoky flavours from bacon as well as chops & boerewors on the braai, peated whisky might just elevate our celebrations even more. We are a hearty nation that thrives under pressure and we celebrate our wins on days filled with fires that fill the neighbourhood with delicious smells.

 By adding the hefty levels of smoke from Islay to the nuances of Highland and Speyside sweetness or taking a smoother turn to peated Irish whiskey, you might just discover a whole new world to elevate your next braai.